
We believe it is imperative that the Department of Education conduct an assessment of arts education.
Music is at the heart of our culture and plays an essential role in children's development. Numerous studies confirm the benefits of music education for child development and the resulting psychosocial benefits such as socialization, empathy, concentration, and perseverance.
However, music education in Quebec's elementary and secondary schools is going through a critical period. For several years now, the professional music community has observed a worrying decline in music education and deplores the fact that it is so undervalued, under-monitored, and under-documented.
Several announcements last spring attest to the decline of music education, notably with the downsizing of the music-study program at La Camaradière school in Quebec City, the abandonment of the program at the Plateau school in La Malbaie, and the relocation of the Face school and its anticipated consequences. However, many more discreet decisions are regularly made in schools that, faced with budgetary challenges, a lack of qualified teachers or adequate space, choose to abandon music education.
However, while it is possible to assess the status of music programs based on data collected by the Ministry of Education, there is no data available to analyze the state of music education in regular elementary and secondary school programs. A compulsory subject between 1937 and 1980, music lost its special status and was integrated into the Quebec school curriculum alongside visual arts, drama, and dance. While arts education remains compulsory, the choice of which artistic discipline is taught is left to the discretion of the school.
As this choice is considered a local educational decision, the Ministry of Education does not collect any data on the disciplines taught, the number of classes or students who have benefited from them, or the conditions under which this teaching is provided. In the past, university researchers have attempted to obtain data on music education by contacting school service centers directly, without much success.
Meanwhile, reports from specialized teachers are multiplying: insufficient teaching hours, inadequate facilities and equipment, uncertainty about whether courses will continue from one year to the next. Increasingly, music education is disappearing altogether.
Given the lack of a documented assessment of the state of music education over the past 45 years and the difficulty of accessing evidence to report on the current situation, we believe it is imperative that the Ministry of Education take stock of arts education in schools and establish a data collection mechanism to monitor the actual state of music education in Quebec's elementary and secondary schools.
In this way, with full knowledge of the facts, in a world where Quebec's identity must be preserved, where artificial intelligence threatens creativity, and where the hegemony of American music dominates music platforms, we can work together to provide quality music education for our next generation of musicians and audiences.
* This letter was also co-signed by: Mélanie La Couture, Chief Executive Officer of the Montreal Symphony Orchestra; Astrid Chouinard, Executive Director of the Quebec Symphony Orchestra; Fabienne Voisin, Executive Director of the Orchestre Métropolitain; Marie-Michelle Raby, Executive Director of the Drummondville Symphony Orchestra; Esther Labrie, Executive Director of the Orchestre symphonique régional de l’Abitibi-Témiscamingue; Stéphanie Girard, Executive Director of the Orchestre symphonique du Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean; Julie Brosseau, Executive Director of the Orchestre symphonique de Trois-Rivières; Guy Bernard, Quebec Musicians' Guild; Sean Ferguson, Dean of the Schulich School of Music at McGill University; Isabelle Héroux, Full Professor at UQAM and member of the Interuniversity Research and Creation Group on Music and Society (RCMS).